In these uncertain econmic times, parents from all tax brackets are re-evaluating their approach when it comes to their child’s education.
Is it really worth paying tens of thousands for my child to attend a top independent school?
Should my money be spent elsewehere?
Can we really afford private school fees?
Will a private education make a significant impact in terms of improving my child’s educational and occupational outcomes?
These are just some of the questions going through the minds of many parents, and it’s perfectly normal.
With some independent day schools costing over £25,000 a year—and boarding schools even more—families are looking at less expensive options to traditional private schooling.
Luckily, the UK is blessed with some outstanding grammar/State schools that provide exceptional learning opportunities and a standard of education that rivals even the most expensive of fee-paying schools.
So, how do you figure out what the best school option is or your child?
As a private tutor who's worked with children from a wide range of schools (including grammar, private, SEND and alternative/hybrid schools), I want to share some straightforward insights that might help parents like yourself to get the clarity needed and make an informed choice that works best for you and your family.
Let’s begin by discussing some key areas:
What Are You Paying For?
Independent schools often claim they offer the following (and more):
Smaller class sizes (sometimes around 1:8)
Personalised support
A wide of extracurricular activities
Strong alumni connections
High Oxbridge, Russell Group and Ivy League acceptance rates
The opportunity for your child to network and socialise with children from elite backgrounds which can help your child to access greater opportunities in future
On the flip side, grammar and outstanding State schools are:
Selective and very academic
Frequently at the top of the school performance rankings
Free, but extremely competitive entrance criteria
Are less likely to have specialised clubs or programmes that enhance soft skills such as mooting societies and chess clubs
TUTORESS TIP
If your child is really academic and self-sufficient, a grammar school might give you great results for a fraction of the cost. However, if your child requires greater levels of support, a private school might be a better fit.
Culture Fit
The environment and overall vibe of a school can shape your child just as much as the curriculum, teaching approach and academic methodology.
In terms of this, private/independent schools can potentially offer:
Polished manners and cultural knowledge
Access to high-end sports (like rowing or polo)
The opportunity to have global/international friends, many of whom become lifelong friends. This is great for networking and building your child’s global and social network.
In comparison, Grammar schools usually offer:
A heavy focus on academic achievement
A more traditional approach to learning
High standards and the expectation of overall excellence
TUTORESS TIP
Visit open days, but don’t just listen to the headteacher—observe the students.
Are they confident yet friendly? Competitive or cooperative? Look for a place that feels right for your child's personality.
Value for Money
When assessing whether to enrol your child in a private or State school, don’t just think short term. Consider whether you can realistically afford to pay school fees for the entire duration of your child’s schooling.
Also consider what will happen if your circumstances change. For example, if there’s a job loss, a change to your health or you have additional responsibilities as a carer to another family member or child.
Ask yourself:
Can I afford to pay my child’s school fees in 3, 4, 5 or 7 years time?
If my circumstances change, can I still afford to make these payments?
What sacrifices (if any) will my family have to make in order for my child to attend this particular fee-paying school?
Will we be able to comfortably make these payments without additional stress to myself or my family?
If you can comfortably afford to pay school fees for your target school and ideally have savings in place in order to pay the fees and any additional school-related costs then opting for a private school makes perfect sense.
However, if there is any uncertainty in the above areas then I would consider exploring the options mentioned towards the end of this article.
An Alternative Approach
If money is tight, don’t overlook the hidden costs of private school (like uniforms, trips, and clubs). If finances are an issue, you might benefit from a hybrid approach while combines attending a grammar/outstanding State school alongside investing in periods of tutoring and specialised mentoring. This hybrid approach of combining the grammar school experience alongside bouts of tutoring, holiday camps, mentoring, coaching, extra curricular activities, frequent travel etc, can offer some children the best of both worlds and could potentially give your child the opportunity to excel academically whilst also developing their soft skills, expanding their cultural capital and developing the social networks, contacts and connections that they might have otherwise gained from attending a private school.
Final Thoughts
The “best” school isn't always the priciest one. It's about finding the school where your child feels safe, inspired, and appropriately challenged. If you're on the fence about this decision, we’re here to help. We offer personalised consultations for families considering their school options, guiding you through everything from entrance exams to long-term education plans. If you’re interested in booking a call, simply complete this form to get in touch.